February 23, 2026
and combine these results with the rate of stellar encounters to determine an optical depth, τs, for scattering (Adamsand Laughlin, 2001; Li and Adams, 2015; Adams et al., 2006; Proszkow and Adams, 2009). This quantity can be written in the form
τs = , n∗ (v σint) dt , (19)
where n∗ is the number density of stars in the system, v is the relative speed between the Sun and other systems, and σint is the interaction cross section. The angular brackets denote averages over both the velocity distribution and the stellar initial mass function for the cluster members.
For interactions in a cluster with velocity dispersion of vc = 1 km/s, and a planet with an aphelion distance of 640 AU (comparable to our best-fit P9 orbital solution obtained in section 5), Li and Adams (2016) derive an ejection cross-section of σint
2.5 106 AU2. Adopting a stellar number density of n = 100 pc–3 and a cluster lifetime of ∆t = 100 Myr, we obtain τs 0.422, which translates to a P9 survival probability
of exp( τs) 2/3. In other words, integrated over the lifetime of the cluster, the probability of ejecting Planet Nine is of order 30%.
Once the solar system emerges from its birth cluster, the probability that Planet Nine can be stripped from the solar system by a passing star diminishes dramatically. In particular, for scattering interactions in the field (Binney and Tremaine, 2008), the stellar density is much lower ( n∗ 0.1 pc–3) and the velocity dispersion is higher (vc 40 km/s). The higher interaction speeds lead to much lower ejection cross sec-
tions (see Li and Adams 2015), which more than compensates for the longer residence time (about 4.5 Gyr). As a result, the corresponding scattering optical depth for the ejection of Planet Nine in the solar neighborhood is essentially negligible – τs 0.002 – 0.02. In other words, once the solar system emerges from its birth cluster, and Planet Nine attains its required orbit, it has an excellent chance of continued survival.
In light of the fact that ejection of planets constitutes a distinct possibility within the early evolution of the solar system, the same reasoning applies to other members of the solar system’s birth cluster. This opens up the possibility that rather than originating within the solar system, Planet Nine was ejected from some other planetary system, and was subsequently captured by the sun’s gravitational field. This P9 capture scenario has been recently considered by a number of authors (Li and Adams, 2016; Mustill et al., 2016; Parker et al., 2017). However, a multitude of requirements must be met in order for successful capture to take place.
One limiting factor is that the scattering encounter must be sufficiently distant so that the cold classical population of the Kuiper Belt (which is likely primordial; Batygin et al. 2012) is not destroyed. This demand implies that the impact parameter exceeds b > 150 200 AU. More constraining is the requirement that the final orbital elements of the captured planet be consistent with those inferred for Planet Nine. For the condi- tions expected in the solar birth cluster, the probability for successful capture is of order a few percent, both for freely floating planets (Li and Adams, 2016), and for planets captured from other planetary systems (Mustill et al., 2016). More recent work (Parker
22Following Li and Adams (2015), we have accounted for the fraction of single (vs binary) stellar encoun- ters by reducing τs by a factor of 2/3.
et al., 2017) finds even lower probabilities, with successful captures of freely floating planets estimated to be only 5 – 10 out of 104. In addition, planet capture is enhanced for expanding, unbound clusters. In contrast, solar system enrichment of short-lived radiogenic isotopes is enhanced for subvirial (partially collapsing) clusters, so some tension exists between the requirement of capturing Planet Nine and explaining mete- oritic enrichment.
Over the past decade and a half, continued detection of minor bodies in the distant solar system has brought the intricate dynamical architecture of the distant Kuiper belt into much sharper focus. Staggeringly, the collective orbital structure of the current census of long-period trans-Neptunian objects offers a number of tantalizing hints at the possibility that an additional massive object – Planet Nine – may be lurking beyond the current observational horizon of the distant solar system. In this work, we have presented a comprehensive review of the observational evidence, as well as the analyti- cal and numerical formulation of the Planet Nine hypothesis. The emergent theoretical picture is summarized in section 8.1, followed by a discussion of alternate explanations for the observed orbital anomalies (section 8.2) and prospects for future work (section 8.3).
The case for the existence of Planet Nine can be organized into the following four primary lines of evidence.
Orbital Alignment of Long-Period KBOs. The observed collection of dynamically stable Kuiper belt objects with semi-major axes in excess of a > 250 AU (orbital peri- ods greater than P & 4000 years), reside on orbits that are clustered together in phys- ical space. This clustering is statistically significant at the 99.8% significance level, and ensues from the simultaneous alignment of the apsidal lines (equivalently, longi-
tudes of perihelion) as well as the orbital planes (which are dictated by the inclinations and the longitudes of ascending node). Because the orbits precess differentially under perturbations from the known giant planets, a sustained restoring gravitational torque is required to preserve the orbital grouping. Dynamical evolution induced by Planet Nine can fully account for the generation and maintenance of the observed alignment of long-period KBOs, while simultaneously allowing for their orbital stability.
Detachment of Perihelia. Long-period KBOs exhibit a broad range of perihelion dis- tances, with a substantial fraction possessing q > 40 AU. Such objects are dynamically decoupled from Neptune, and cannot be created during Kuiper belt formation via in- teractions with the known planets alone. As a result, this population of KBOs requires external gravitational perturbations to lift their perihelia. Within the framework of the Planet Nine hypothesis, the same dynamics that are responsible for the aforementioned apsidal alignment also provide a means of generating Neptune-detached Kuiper belt objects, thereby explaining their origins.
Excitation of Extreme TNO Inclinations. Trans-Neptunian objects with inclinations in excess of i & 50 deg are not a natural outcome of the solar system formation process. Nevertheless, several objects with inclinations well above 50 deg have been detected on wide (a > 250 AU) orbits, including the recently discovered KBO 2015 BP519 which is the only known member of this class characterized by q > 30 AU. Despite their puz- zling nature, such highly inclined objects are routinely produced within the framework
of the P9 hypothesis, via a high order (octupolar) secular resonance with Planet Nine.
Production of Retrograde Centaurs. In addition to long-period TNOs with i > 50 deg, the solar system also hosts a multitude of highly inclined, and even strongly retrograde shorter-period (a < 100 AU) objects. As with their distant counterparts, the dynam- ical origins of such objects is inexplicable through perturbations from the known gi- ant planets alone. Although these objects are decoupled from Planet Nine’s gravita- tional influence today, numerical simulations demonstrate that an intricate interplay between P9-induced dynamical evolution and Neptune scattering can deliver highly inclined long-period TNOs onto shorter period orbits, polluting the classical region of the Kuiper belt with highly inclined Centaurs. More generally, this process allows for the injection of objects that trace through orbits in the retrograde direction, into the trans-Jovian domain of the solar system.
Each of the above dynamical effects can be understood from purely analytic grounds within the framework of the Planet Nine hypothesis. Simplified models of this sort, based on secular perturbation theory, are presented in section 4. Detailed comparison with the data, however, requires the fabrication of a synthetic population of long-period KBOs using large-scale N-body simulations. The results of thousands of such simu- lations are described in section 5, and collectively point to a revised set of physical and orbital parameters for Planet Nine. Specifically, compared to the original results
(Batygin and Brown, 2016a), where P9 was reported to have m9 10M⊕ and occupy an a9 = 700 AU orbit with e9 = 0.6, the current simulations (reviewed in section 5), point towards a marginally lower-mass planet that resides on a somewhat more prox- imate and less dynamically excited orbit, with m9 5 10M⊕, a9 400 800 AU, e9 0.2 0.5, and i9 15 25 deg. Perhaps counterintuitively, the increase in bright- ness due to a smaller heliocentric distance more than makes up for the decrease in brightness due to a slightly diminished physical radius, suggesting that Planet Nine is more readily discoverable by conventional optical surveys than previously thought.
As a formulated dynamical model, the Planet Nine hypothesis provides a satisfac- tory account for the orbital anomalies of the distant solar system. Nevertheless, until the existence of Planet Nine is confirmed observationally, the possibility that the envi- sioned theory is incorrect will continue to linger. The history of proposed planets based on dynamical anomalies suggests that this option should be taken seriously. In this vein, it is useful to recall the cautionary tale surrounding the prediction and subsequent abandonment of planet Vulcan (see section 1.3), as it illuminates the vulnerability of even the most well-formulated theoretical models.
While it is unlikely that the asym- metries of the orbital structure of the distant solar system point to fundamentally new physics (as in the case of Vulcan), we must acknowledge alternative explanations for the observations that do not invoke the existence of Planet Nine. These ideas generally fall into two distinct categories, and we briefly discuss their attributes below.
Observational Bias. If the Planet Nine hypothesis proves to be unnecessary, perhaps the most likely explanation is that no explanation is required. One can envision a sce- nario where the observational strategy and serendipity conspire to produce the observed patterns in the data. In this case, the apparent clustering in longitudes of perihelion and orbital poles would be spurious, and the underlying distribution of orbital angles of the distant solar system objects would be uniform (e.g., Lawler et al., 2017; Shankman et al., 2017).
The upshot here is that this interpretation can be quantified by a well-defined sta- tistical likelihood. As discussed in section 3, the associated false-alarm probability is estimated to be less than one percent (Brown and Batygin, 2019). Beyond angular clustering alone, the statistical significance of the Planet Nine hypothesis is further re- inforced by the fact that multiple lines of evidence all point to the same Planet Nine model. Specifically, not only can the orbital alignment of the distant TNOs be under- stood in terms of a new planet, the existence of perihelion-detached objects, as well as the generation of the observed high inclination objects also naturally emerge within the framework of the same theoretical model. While observational bias can never be completely ruled out as an explanation for the data, continued detection of long-period Kuiper belt objects (e.g., Sheppard et al. 2018; Khain et al. 2018b, etc) will lead to further refinement of the false-alarm probability.
Self-Gravity of the Distant Kuiper Belt. A separate class of models posit that the ob- served structure of the distant solar system is real but is not sculpted by a planet, and instead arises from the collective gravity of the distant Kuiper belt. The first of these theories is due to Madigan and McCourt (2016), who propose that the distant solar sys-
tem contains 1 10M⊕ of unseen material. Over Gyr timescales, this population of objects experiences coupled inclination-eccentricity evolution – a process the authors
refer to as the “inclination instability” (see Madigan et al. 2018 for further discussion). The development of this instability results in a clustered distribution of the arguments of perihelion of the constituent bodies, in agreement with the anomalous pattern first pointed out by Trujillo and Sheppard (2014). However, this model provides no ex- planation for the observed confinement in the longitudes of perihelion as well as the angular momentum vectors, and thus fails to reproduce the actual observed structure of the distant belt. Moreover, the inclination instability does not naturally manifest in numerical simulations of Kuiper belt emplacement that self-consistently account for self-gravity of the planetesimal disk, calling into question the specificity of initial con- ditions required for this model to operate (Fan and Batygin, 2017).
A different self-gravity model has been recently proposed by Sefilian & Touma (2018). In this theory, instead of the observed Kuiper belt contributing to the collective potential of the trans-Neptunian region, there exists a moderately eccentric (e ~ 0.2) shepherding disk that extends from ain = 40 AU to aout = 750 AU, comprising 10M⊕ of material in total. The gravitational potential of this disk creates a stable, apsidally
anti-aligned secular equilibrium at high eccentricity that facilitates the confinement ofthe longitudes of perihelion of the observed long-period KBOs (which act as test par- ticles, enslaved by the disk’s potential). In light of the fact that the primary mode of dynamical evolution induced by Planet Nine itself is secular in nature (and in an orbit-averaged sense, the gravitational potential of Planet Nine is not different from a massive wire that traces its orbit), there are clear mathematical similarities that ensue between this model and the analytical formulation of the P9 hypothesis (section 4). Nevertheless, from the point of view of planet formation, the prolonged existence of the envisioned shepherding disk suffers from many of the same drawbacks outlined
in section 7.1 (e.g., radiative stripping of r & 50 AU protoplanetary disk material, disruptive perturbations due to passing stars in the birth cluster, etc.) as well as the ap-
parent incompatibility with the striking decrease in observed number of KBOs beyond
a & 48 AU.
One result of this review is that numerical simulations containing Planet Nine can produce orbits that are in good agreement with the observed structure of the distant Kuiper belt. Nonetheless, a number of theoretical questions remain unanswered, and their resolution may help illuminate the path toward the direct detection of the most distant planetary member of the solar system. As a result, we conclude this article with a brief (and incomplete) discussion of some problems that remain open within the broader framework of the Planet Nine hypothesis.
The Inclination Dispersion of Jupiter-Family Comets. The inward scattering of TNOs that have been strongly influenced by Planet Nine constitutes a dynamical pathway through which highly inclined icy bodies can be delivered to much smaller heliocen- tric distances. In this way, Planet Nine can affect not only the orbital properties of the Kuiper belt itself, but the inclination dispersion of Jupiter-Family comets, which are sourced from the trans-Neptunian region (Duncan et al., 1988). In a recent study, Nesvorny´ et al. (2017) carried out detailed simulations of the generation and evolution
of short-period comets, and found that inclusion of a m9 = 15M⊕ Planet Nine that resides on a a = 700 AU, e = 0.6 orbit leads to a simulated inclination dispersion of Jupiter-Family comets that is broader than its observed counterpart.
Importantly, however, the simulation suite presented in section 5 of this work fa- vors a lower mass, more circular Planet Nine over the parameters adopted by Nesvorny´ et al. (2017). Because the inclination excitation of long-period TNOs is driven by octupole-level secular interactions with P9, we can reasonably expect that our revised P9 parameters would significantly diminish both the rate, and the efficiency of high-i comet generation, potentially eliminating any discrepancy between the observed and modeled orbital distributions. A quantitative evaluation of the possibility is of substan- tial interest.
Contamination of the Distant Kuiper Belt. Within the current observational sample of distant KBOs, orbital clustering exhibited by long-term (meta)stable KBOs is consid- erably tighter than that of the unstable objects. Qualitatively, this disparity is sensible since unstable objects actively interact with Neptune, and can be
rapidly perturbed away from P9-sculpted dynamical states. Moreover, given their rapid excursions in
No comments:
Post a Comment